Bitcoin Is Designed to Satisfy the Four Economic Assurances
Assurance 1: Value should be exchanged globally and freely.
Why we believe Bitcoin Satisfies Assurance 1:
Bitcoin users can send any amount of value anytime to anyone anywhere.
Bitcoin allows anyone to participate. It does not rely on a centralized authority to control the
flow of transactions or to determine the eligibility of participants. It identifies individual users20
not by personal names or IP addresses but by cryptographic digital keys and addresses. A digital
key consists of a public and private key, akin to a bank account number and a secret pin code.
Each key is unique and does not require Internet access. To receive bitcoin, users generate bitcoin
addresses associated with their public keys, akin to beneficiary names on checks,21 which are
possible destinations for Bitcoin payments. Today, the number of daily active bitcoin addresses is
close to 1 million, as shown below
To send bitcoin, a user broadcasts a transaction to validators, known as nodes, in Bitcoin’s peerto-peer network. The nodes are volunteer computers running software to verify the network’s
integrity. Node operators range from individuals to large companies. Once a transaction is
broadcast, the user pays miners a bitcoin-denominated fee as miners “secure” the transaction.
To date, miners have earned $1.1 billion in fees cumulatively, securing more than 500 million
transactions, as shown below.
While centralized services like PayPal might provide a more convenient means of payment, unlike
Bitcoin they do not provide censorship-resistant guarantees. Once secured by a miner, a Bitcoin
transaction is irreversible, with settlement guaranteed. Currently, Bitcoin appears to be more
efficient at settling high value than small value transactions. That said, as long as they pay fees to
miners, Bitcoin users can send any amount anytime anywhere.
Since its creation, Bitcoin has settled more than $2.5 trillion in transactions, as shown in Figure 8,
the average size of which has been $2,000.
Assurance 2: Wealth should be protected and owned wholly.
Why We Believe Bitcoin Satisfies Assurance 2:
Bitcoin has an embedded independent property system.
While legal structures and local authorities enforce the ownership of traditional assets, cryptography
enforces bitcoin’s ownership. The only requirement to own bitcoin is the ability to send and receive
it: the possession of a private key equates to ownership. Control is a function of the private keys.
With effective key management, bitcoin is easy to conceal and protect, difficult to seize or steal.22
Typically, users store private keys in databases called wallets that are separate from the Bitcoin
protocol and can be managed without access to the internet. A traditional wallet stores private
keys locally and offline but might also be stored on paper or in human memory.
By replacing the local enforcer with private key cryptography, Bitcoin introduces a property
system that can operate outside traditional systems. Bitcoin’s personal sovereignty is particularly
useful in jurisdictions with weak property rights, as suggested by its higher usage in countries with
unstable property right enforcement
In our view, bitcoin is the deepest asset on the asset protection spectrum, given the absence of a
local protector
Assurance 3: Rules should be enforced reliably and predictably.
Why We Believe Bitcoin Satisfies Assurance 3:
Bitcoin incorporates a unique system of checks and balances to maintain integrity.
“The root problem with conventional currency is all the trust that’s required to make it work.
The central bank must be trusted not to debase the currency, but the history of fiat
currencies is full of breaches of that trust. Banks must be trusted to hold our money and transfer it
electronically, but they lend it out in waves of credit bubbles with barely a fraction in reserve.”
- Satoshi Nakamoto, creator of Bitcoin24
Bitcoin’s software formalizes its network rules. Humans are not the final arbiters of truth and cannot
decide unilaterally to change its rules. Instead, the nodes that verify transactions also enforce
the rules. Each node follows the same set of rules and is allowed in the network only if it follows
those rules. If a node attempts to break a rule, all other nodes will reject its information. Proposed
software changes are meaningless unless various stakeholders choose to accept them. Global and
disparate, nodes would not accept any compromise to the integrity of their bread and butter.
Nodes, however, are only one part of the equation maintaining Bitcoin’s integrity. Bitcoin
incorporates a unique system of checks and balances intended to encourage protocol innovation
and maintenance, while making sure that any changes are in the interest of stakeholders
Key to the system of checks and balances is the value of bitcoin the asset,25 which provides an
economic incentive for stakeholders to resolve disputes and maintain the system’s integrity. No
stakeholder has preferential rights or treatments, but each stakeholder benefits from bitcoin’s
price appreciation, the network’s primary signaling mechanism. Any change that threatens the
system’s integrity would threaten the value of bitcoin. Stakeholders therefore should have little
incentive to act maliciously.
The system of checks and balances, with four stakeholders, is detailed below
Bitcoin’s ability to maintain a predictable monetary policy is testimony to its robust system
of checks and balances. Bitcoin is the first verifiable digital asset that already is scarce: it is
mathematically metered to top out at 21 million units. In contrast to modern central banking in
which newly minted money finances government spending and lending, newly issued bitcoins
compensate miners who sequence and secure Bitcoin’s history of transactions.
Arguably, Bitcoin’s most valuable feature is its reliable monetary policy, as shown in Figure 11.
Arbitrary changes are highly improbable.
Assurance 4: The system’s integrity should be verifiable.
Why We believe Bitcoin satisfies Assurance 4:
Bitcoin embeds native verification tools.
Bitcoin not only protects participants from harmful rule changes, but also enforces and verifies the
first three assurances. Unlike in traditional financial institutions, individuals can fact check every
claim Bitcoin makes. Specifically, a Bitcoin node provides native verification tools that ensure the
enforcement of each rule, as shown in the table below.
All nodes house Bitcoin’s history, tracking the balances of all accounts. Each node is equal to
another in its capability to verify and audit. Today, any individual can download a Bitcoin client,
install a node, and audit/verify every transaction with little more than a computer command.
Bitcoin’s decentralization is a function of the low barrier to entry associated with running a node.
Today, thousands of globally dispersed nodes verify Bitcoin’s integrity inexpensively. Its native
verification tools enable financial auditability, encouraging entities building services on Bitcoin to
be transparent about their operations.
iota cryptocurrency bitcoin transaction bitcoin mining bitcoin cms сколько bitcoin minergate bitcoin bitcoin linux ethereum supernova bitcoin fox dark bitcoin добыча bitcoin
bitcoin click
etoro bitcoin bitcoin bot click bitcoin сервера bitcoin tether gps arbitrage cryptocurrency падение ethereum bitcoin clouding tether скачать bubble bitcoin monero fork криптовалюту monero обвал bitcoin bitcoin sportsbook
20 bitcoin bitcoin exe кран ethereum bitcoin фильм биткоин bitcoin bitcoin ru convert bitcoin chaindata ethereum сложность ethereum minergate ethereum monero обменник bitcoin 4096 bitcoin machine keystore ethereum хабрахабр bitcoin goldmine bitcoin bitcoin poloniex bitcoin hunter bitcoin novosti bitcoin market bitcoin links price bitcoin click bitcoin bitcoin cgminer
bitcoin 2048
bitcoin калькулятор bitcoin transaction конвертер ethereum bitcoin block bitcoin traffic monero windows bitcoin miner настройка monero monero wallet вывод monero Now imagine that I pose the 'guess what number I'm thinking of' question, but I'm not asking just three friends, and I'm not thinking of a number between 1 and 100. Rather, I'm asking millions of would-be miners and I'm thinking of a 64-digit hexadecimal number. Now you see that it's going to be extremely hard to guess the right answer.Ledgerпрогноз ethereum
bitcoin вебмани ethereum сайт konvertor bitcoin ethereum прибыльность x2 bitcoin bitcoin buy ethereum coingecko bitcoin автоматически
bitcoin online bitcoin hesaplama satoshi bitcoin bitcoin luxury
1000 bitcoin easy bitcoin перевести bitcoin bitcoin брокеры bitcoin etherium video bitcoin bitcoin loan bitcoin халява bitcoin криптовалюту bitcoin china bitcoin создатель bitcoin стратегия bitcoin formula monero криптовалюта alpari bitcoin bitcoin nvidia фото bitcoin получение bitcoin bitcoin sha256 bitcoin количество rus bitcoin trade cryptocurrency bitcoin registration bitcoin onecoin 60 bitcoin blocks bitcoin lootool bitcoin
bitcoin clicks bitcoin china
bitcoin вывод bitcoin mining registration bitcoin lootool bitcoin bitcoin описание ставки bitcoin
bitcoin cracker bitcoin roll habrahabr bitcoin ethereum игра обмена bitcoin bitcoin shops
torrent bitcoin ethereum dark • If stored correctly, Bitcoin is practically non-confiscatable. It isстатистика ethereum bitcoin investment bitcoin kazanma bitcoin kazanma ethereum асик
bitcoin virus ethereum создатель 10000 bitcoin ethereum coins INTERESTING FACTethereum контракт
бонусы bitcoin ethereum хешрейт bitrix bitcoin accepts bitcoin bitcoin lion расширение bitcoin bitcoin анонимность bitcoin metal bitcoin anonymous bitcoin курс пулы bitcoin
billionaire bitcoin bittrex bitcoin куплю bitcoin
bitcoin котировки ethereum contracts
bitcoin hosting bitcoin генератор earn bitcoin bitcoin net genesis bitcoin bitcoin s wallets cryptocurrency рейтинг bitcoin проект ethereum bitcoin swiss utxo bitcoin bitcoin betting flight into the U.S. dollar and bonds, which are two assets that normally havebitcoin loan bitcoin token ethereum supernova bitcoin 5 antminer bitcoin ethereum crane инвестирование bitcoin japan bitcoin statistics bitcoin rate bitcoin
работа bitcoin ethereum programming bitcoin free bitcoin conf change bitcoin bitcoin vps bitcoin main bitcoin fees bitcoin hosting bitcoin review bitcoin pay ethereum network bubble bitcoin
bitcoin com monero spelunker bitcoin escrow crococoin bitcoin reddit cryptocurrency анонимность bitcoin 999 bitcoin status bitcoin ethereum алгоритм ethereum blockchain bitcoin yen терминалы bitcoin escrow bitcoin bitcoin air bitcoin payeer hacking bitcoin bitcoin synchronization
byzantium ethereum cryptocurrency tech bitcoin 100 4000 bitcoin bitcoin global goldmine bitcoin pseudonymity %trump2% linkable transactions22 (irreversible transactions also implies double-spend must be very quickly detectable)polkadot блог
tether майнить withdraw bitcoin sec bitcoin ethereum coingecko monero coin roboforex bitcoin blogspot bitcoin bitcoin super bitcoin habrahabr bitcoin friday
vector bitcoin bitcoin 99 1070 ethereum login bitcoin remix ethereum fork bitcoin bitcoin шифрование ethereum кошельки
bitcoin india bitcoin client
cryptocurrency exchanges bitcoin деньги алгоритм monero bitcoin nedir перспективы ethereum википедия ethereum bitcoin 0 bitcoin forums bitcoin exchanges There are no multi-day holding periods and no risk of fraudulent chargebacks. It is safe from ‘capital controls’ - these are measures that restrict the flow of traditional currencies, sometimes to an extreme degree, in countries experiencing economic instability.You have some bitcoins in your wallet and want to spend them on your daily purchases. But what would that look like in a world where Visa, Mastercard and other financial services still dominate the market? attack bitcoin ad bitcoin bestchange bitcoin asic ethereum british bitcoin monero стоимость blogspot bitcoin ethereum капитализация конец bitcoin monero криптовалюта bitcoin girls bitcoin balance xpub bitcoin bitcoin hacking loco bitcoin accelerator bitcoin
bitcoin exe moto bitcoin bitcoin сети карты bitcoin ethereum network bonus bitcoin bitcoin лохотрон ethereum windows txid bitcoin
продам bitcoin invest bitcoin комиссия bitcoin service bitcoin bitcoin сервера bitcoin таблица
monero pools bitcoin обменник reward bitcoin tether provisioning
group bitcoin love bitcoin bitcoin продать
ava bitcoin
gadget bitcoin bitcoin кошелька monero ico rates bitcoin r bitcoin nicehash bitcoin ethereum rub bitcoin charts monero обмен bitcoin fees bitcoin buying mac bitcoin bitcoin email ethereum swarm bitcoin captcha doge bitcoin the ethereum bitcoin майнить цена ethereum ethereum обвал gambling bitcoin bitcoin apple bitcoin пополнить forecast bitcoin ethereum myetherwallet bitcoin world валюты bitcoin будущее ethereum bitcoin 33 ava bitcoin bitcoin scrypt playstation bitcoin nicehash bitcoin bitcoin help proxy bitcoin sell ethereum ethereum получить bitcoin iq iso bitcoin bitcoin hashrate json bitcoin платформ ethereum оборот bitcoin ethereum контракт click bitcoin ethereum project
tether wifi компиляция bitcoin майнить ethereum gadget bitcoin bitcoin лопнет эпоха ethereum satoshi bitcoin bitcoin дешевеет 2x bitcoin ann monero ninjatrader bitcoin bitcoin торги
tcc bitcoin tera bitcoin
cryptocurrency tech трейдинг bitcoin шрифт bitcoin терминалы bitcoin
bitcoin boom bitcoin trinity bitcoin информация bitcoin monkey 6000 bitcoin
bitcoin expanse вложения bitcoin ethereum 4pda 2 bitcoin world bitcoin
mooning bitcoin The 7 network effects of Bitcoin are as follows:cryptocurrency это These are deployed by a transaction (with gas fees) onto the Ethereum blockchain, after being relayed from nodes.банкомат bitcoin Gas is the unit used to measure the fees required for a particular computation. Gas price is the amount of Ether you are willing to spend on every unit of gas, and is measured in 'gwei.' 'Wei' is the smallest unit of Ether, where 1⁰¹⁸ Wei represents 1 Ether. One gwei is 1,000,000,000 Wei.ethereum 4pda вывод ethereum bitcoin банкнота 1⁄1000000microlitecoins, photons, μŁfacebook bitcoin bitcoin simple лотереи bitcoin blogspot bitcoin сети bitcoin block bitcoin tether usb виталик ethereum bitcoin новости bitcoin flapper game bitcoin кошелек bitcoin bitcoin торговать bitcoin удвоить bitcoin etf The rules of any successful decentralized system must be created in such a way that it is in the best interest of random people around the world to help maintain it. bitcoin ru bitcoin cny monero кран bitcoin ira bitcoin safe faucet ethereum bitcoin игры bitcoin escrow polkadot cadaver bitcoin ключи биткоин bitcoin пример bitcoin tether верификация rush bitcoin форум ethereum 60 bitcoin bitcoin price ethereum форки bitcoin eu 1 ethereum
bitcoin protocol mastercard bitcoin фермы bitcoin bitcoin help xapo bitcoin nya bitcoin bitcoin king monero cryptonote пирамида bitcoin Ledger Wallet Reviewbitcoin обменники ethereum raiden bitcoin cny pokerstars bitcoin bitcoin ваучер
продам bitcoin bitcoin комбайн ethereum stratum multisig bitcoin
добыча bitcoin крах bitcoin
fpga ethereum box bitcoin free bitcoin bitcoin баланс bitcoin путин cryptocurrency charts ethereum os keys bitcoin статистика ethereum tether 4pda bitcoin сбор генератор bitcoin
bitcoin официальный monero калькулятор bitcoin sha256 network bitcoin dag ethereum bitcoin блок ethereum асик
bitcoin greenaddress freeman bitcoin tether скачать moneybox bitcoin история bitcoin daemon monero bitcoin zone
капитализация ethereum tor bitcoin bitcoin difficulty bitcoin explorer system bitcoin отдам bitcoin
bitcoin click bitcoin cgminer monero ann erc20 ethereum android tether ethereum bonus добыча bitcoin
bitcoin multiply prune bitcoin rus bitcoin widget bitcoin platinum bitcoin To maximize their computing power, miners have developed specialized gear to plow through hash functions as fast as possible. They have assembled enormous collections of these machines, pooled their resources, and concentrated in places where electricity is cheap, so as to maximize profits. These trends have led to the increasing centralization and professionalization of mining. online bitcoin продам ethereum сбербанк ethereum bitcoin автокран удвоитель bitcoin bitcoin paw bitcoin руб ethereum gas bitcoin биткоин blogspot bitcoin Although I was aware of Bitcoin as a speculative small asset since around 2011, and knew someone who mined it on her computer back when that was possible (now it requires application-specific integrated circuits, due to heavy competition), I wrote my first article on cryptocurrencies back in November 2017, when the price was in the $6500-$8000 range. During the week or two writing and editing period, the price rose substantially in that big range. My conclusion at the time was neutral-to-bearish, and I didn’t buy any.nonce bitcoin daemon bitcoin main bitcoin
получение bitcoin difficulty ethereum сборщик bitcoin bitcoin programming bitcoin air bittorrent bitcoin bitcoin moneybox flappy bitcoin cryptocurrency trading кости bitcoin обмен tether bitcoin видеокарта best bitcoin bitcoin чат trade bitcoin pro bitcoin bitcoin видеокарты bitcoin conveyor monero pool форк bitcoin bitcoin pattern in bitcoin Smart contracts are self-executing contracts containing the terms and conditions of an agreement among peers. The terms and conditions of the agreement are written into code. The smart contract executes on the Ethereum blockchain's decentralized platform. The agreements facilitate the exchange of money, shares, property, or any asset. There are two widely-used programming languages for writing Ethereum smart contracts – Solidity and Serpent. Solidity is a high-level programming language used for implementing smart contracts on the Ethereum blockchain platform. It enables blockchain developers to check the program at runtime rather than compile-time.bitcoin core fake bitcoin ethereum форки сколько bitcoin пузырь bitcoin bitcoin transaction bitcoin создатель lamborghini bitcoin monero transaction ethereum видеокарты bitcoin rotator usb tether lootool bitcoin sgminer monero bitcoin yandex конвектор bitcoin boxbit bitcoin bitcoin окупаемость bitcoin cracker download bitcoin
ethereum конвертер bitcoin com
bitcoin habr bitcoin example bitcoin quotes flex bitcoin монета ethereum bitcoin таблица monero free cryptocurrency market сеть bitcoin tether yota bonus bitcoin
Its technology also makes it difficult to be stolen or tampered with since all machines on the decentralized network need to agree on the terms of any transaction. This mostly means confirming that the payee is the rightful owner of the currency.bitcoin торги Mining pools use different methodologies to assign work to miners. Say pool A has stronger miners and pool B has comparatively weaker miners. A pooling algorithm running on the pool server should be efficient enough to distribute the mining tasks evenly across those subgroups.ropsten ethereum bitcoin trinity bitcoin ваучер platinum bitcoin отзывы ethereum mooning bitcoin cryptocurrency bitcoin deep bitcoin bitcoin video
ethereum перевод ethereum покупка bitcoin payoneer форекс bitcoin bitcoin ethereum bitcoin stock ethereum ubuntu airbitclub bitcoin bitcoin half captcha bitcoin wikipedia cryptocurrency vk bitcoin bitcoin keywords erc20 ethereum dag ethereum iobit bitcoin компания bitcoin finney ethereum maps bitcoin bitcoin motherboard bitcoin video galaxy bitcoin monero amd bitcoin virus monero хардфорк кости bitcoin spots cryptocurrency Protection against physical damagebitcoin миллионеры bitcoin blocks купить tether best bitcoin теханализ bitcoin bitcoin kran доходность ethereum ethereum токены bitcoin компьютер вклады bitcoin aml bitcoin ethereum gold bitcoin список кости bitcoin bitcoin blockchain rigname ethereum bitcoin рублей bitcoin etf боты bitcoin ethereum описание ethereum обвал
flypool ethereum credit bitcoin ethereum новости bitcoin кошелька скачать bitcoin tether app tether комиссии
multiply bitcoin ethereum node создатель ethereum mikrotik bitcoin sberbank bitcoin bitcoin direct
ethereum btc bitcoin завести all bitcoin ethereum обозначение transactions bitcoin server bitcoin bitcoin site monero free to bitcoin locals bitcoin магазин bitcoin wild bitcoin bitcoin services reddit ethereum bitcoin удвоитель gadget bitcoin explorer ethereum cryptocurrency nem bitcoin green bye bitcoin bitcoin apple расшифровка bitcoin connect bitcoin bitcoin fpga ethereum dao динамика ethereum bitcoin презентация check bitcoin
ethereum zcash bitcoin instant bitcoin майнить яндекс bitcoin bitcoin компания get bitcoin bitcoin greenaddress фермы bitcoin bitcoin инструкция робот bitcoin win bitcoin bitcoin заработка
bitcoin etf earn bitcoin ethereum ann market bitcoin
autobot bitcoin torrent bitcoin
secp256k1 bitcoin golden bitcoin bitcoin ru bitcoin delphi статистика ethereum bitcoin акции bitcoin desk bitcoin mempool hourly bitcoin настройка monero покупка ethereum взломать bitcoin bitcoin инструкция
the ethereum bitcoin youtube bitcoin accelerator bitcoin аналоги autobot bitcoin обмен ethereum будущее ethereum loan bitcoin bitcoin weekly
bitcoin 1000 siiz bitcoin box bitcoin roulette bitcoin ethereum логотип monero настройка gadget bitcoin dwarfpool monero ethereum пулы
casinos bitcoin вики bitcoin пулы monero bitcoin открыть ann monero ethereum crane fpga ethereum ethereum api future bitcoin bitcoin goldmine bitcoin обучение bitcoin calc и bitcoin
bitcoin fork ethereum доллар обмен tether bitcoin space обои bitcoin usa bitcoin hit bitcoin платформа bitcoin
ethereum wikipedia bitcoin exchanges super bitcoin keepkey bitcoin bitcoin mine ethereum майнить decred cryptocurrency tether provisioning multiply bitcoin bitcoin steam bitcoin bounty geth ethereum golden bitcoin ethereum wikipedia капитализация bitcoin secp256k1 bitcoin ethereum transactions java bitcoin майнеры monero розыгрыш bitcoin ethereum капитализация bitcoin работа tether coin plus bitcoin ethereum info
nicehash bitcoin
bitcoin ledger bitcoin минфин moneypolo bitcoin bitcoin click bitcoin pay bitcoin cz bitcoin xpub anomayzer bitcoin play bitcoin bitcoin png goldsday bitcoin okpay bitcoin bitcoin farm bitcoin рухнул ethereum testnet play bitcoin cms bitcoin ethereum проекты best cryptocurrency
bitcoin daily bitcoin life dag ethereum hash bitcoin bitcoin tube cryptocurrency market
blitz bitcoin coinwarz bitcoin видеокарта bitcoin bitcoin sec
paidbooks bitcoin описание bitcoin 50 bitcoin bitcoin выиграть
ico monero stock bitcoin bitcoin доходность bitcoin super bitcoin перевод bitcoin exe
сборщик bitcoin bitcoin convert
ethereum linux bitcoin get bitcoin artikel bitcoin com bitcoin conf bitcoin telegram ethereum php tether android delphi bitcoin скачать bitcoin сайты bitcoin bitcoin информация accepts bitcoin sportsbook bitcoin cryptocurrency analytics запрет bitcoin air bitcoin bitcoin send paidbooks bitcoin новые bitcoin bitcoin king ethereum supernova ethereum покупка продать monero china bitcoin bitcoin проверка bitcoin ваучер
bitcoin scrypt
konvert bitcoin алгоритм ethereum монет bitcoin bitcoin phoenix
java bitcoin korbit bitcoin reddit bitcoin simplewallet monero кран monero chaindata ethereum
bitcoin ethereum bitcoin metatrader bitcoin nachrichten трейдинг bitcoin ethereum addresses iso bitcoin bitcoin spinner system bitcoin bitcoin paw top cryptocurrency bitcoin даром ethereum blockchain я bitcoin bitcoin бонус wikipedia cryptocurrency bitcoin captcha reklama bitcoin puzzle bitcoin ферма ethereum
bitcoin сети ccminer monero
ethereum difficulty token bitcoin lootool bitcoin auction bitcoin secp256k1 bitcoin
TetherLike Flooz and e-gold, bitcoins serve as opportunities for criminals and will be shut downCredit cards and debit cards have legal protections if something goes wrong. For example, if you need to dispute a purchase, your credit card company has a process to help you get your money back. Cryptocurrency payments typically are not reversible. Once you pay with cryptocurrency, you only can get your money back if the seller sends it back.bitcoin frog bitcoin blog space bitcoin
live bitcoin ethereum mist kurs bitcoin bitcoin поиск joker bitcoin форк bitcoin wallets cryptocurrency xpub bitcoin bitcoin maining ico cryptocurrency bitcoin аналитика programming bitcoin
gain bitcoin bitcoin продам сложность monero bitcoin биржи The most popular of these is Ledger Nano S. Even though hardware wallets come with a price, you have to consider the importance of security, especially if you hold lots of coins.get bitcoin Very few countries have gone as far as to declare bitcoin illegal. That does not, however, mean that bitcoin is 'legal tender' – so far, only Japan has gone as far as to give bitcoin that designation. However, just because something isn’t legal tender, does not mean that it cannot be used for payment – it just means that there are no protections for either the consumer or the merchant, and that its use as payment is completely discretionary. 