Why Bitcoin is Different
If you’re new to the Bitcoin space, the last few months have been pretty crazy. There have been some steep climbs and heart-stopping drops making for a roller coaster of emotion that’s not easily controlled. The price action is both thrilling and at times, painful, so it’s easy to lose sight of what you’re investing in. All the coins seem to be running together, so what’s the difference? How is one coin to be distinguished from another? And more importantly, how is an investor to know what the long term value of a coin will be?
Image for post
In this article, I’m going to make the case for what makes Bitcoin different, how Bitcoin is a system that, despite all the cloning, has yet to be truly replicated.
Real Innovation
To really understand the value proposition of Bitcoin, it helps to look at a bit of history. It’s tempting to think that the newest ICO or altcoin is the one that will finally “improve” Bitcoin and fix all of its problems and that Bitcoin will be relegated to the dustbin of history due to its lack of some “feature”. Indeed, nearly every altcoin, ICO or hardfork thinks that they’re being innovative in some fundamental way. What’s missed is that the biggest innovation has already happened.
Decentralized digital scarcity is the real innovation and Bitcoin was the first, and, as this article will make clear, continues to be the only such coin. All the other so-called innovations such as faster confirmation times, changing to proof-of-whatever, Turing completeness, different signature algorithm, different transaction ordering method and even privacy, are really tiny variations on the giant innovation that is Bitcoin.
It’s important to remember here that alternatives to Bitcoin have been proposed since 2011 and none of them have even come close to displacing Bitcoin in terms of price, usage or security. IxCoin was a clone of Bitcoin created in 2011 with larger block rewards and a premine (large number of coins sent to the creator). Tenebrix was an altcoin created in 2011 that tried to add GPU resistance and again had a large premine. Solidcoin was another altcoin created in 2011 with faster block times and again, a premine. About the only ones that survived (and not living out a zombie existence) out of that early altcoin era are Namecoin and Litecoin, which distinguished themselves by NOT having a premine.
ICOs are also not new. Mastercoin did an ICO in 2013 with, you guessed it, a premine, and raised over 5000 BTC at the time and had to rebrand themselves to Omni because the ecosystem around it was so anemic. Factom did an ICO in 2015 and raised over 2000 BTC and had to raise multiple rounds of additional financing because they ran out of money. In other words, all these “exciting” new tokens have generally done very poorly and didn’t actually provide much utility.
Altcoins and ICOs have tried many different “features” and most have not been useful or adopted. So what gives? Why does Bitcoin seem to have a special place in the ecosystem? Why is Bitcoin different? We explore two unique aspects that make Bitcoin different than everything else: the network effect and decentralization.
The Network Effect
Because Bitcoin has the largest network and gains from the network effect, other coins essentially are playing a giant game of catch-up. Bitcoin is the 7-day week and every other altcoin is a slight variation (Let’s have 4-day weeks! Let’s make the day 18 hours! Let’s rename the days to something different! Let’s vary week lengths according to the whims of a central authority!) Needless to say, these types of “innovations” are, at best, minor and are generally not adopted. This is because the network effect of Bitcoin grows over time and the people using the network optimize toward the standards of the network, locking more and more people in.
As the network grows, what we see is that subtle, unseen benefits accrue to each norm. What may, on the surface seem inefficient actually has second and third order effects that benefit the people conforming to the norm. For example, a car does not fly or go on water because the car has been optimized for use on solid ground. The lack of extra features makes the car more useful since it’s easier to park (smaller size than a theoretical boat/car/plane hybrid), cheaper to maintain and get fuel for, etc.
In addition, these norms have withstood the test of time and have proven their resilience in ways that are not obvious. You would not want to be the first person to fly in a car/plane hybrid, for example, because you wouldn’t know how safe such a vehicle is. Something that’s been around has proven its relative security. Bitcoin, in a sense, has the world’s richest bug bounty to reveal any security flaws. As a result, Bitcoin has proven its security with the only thing that can really test it: time. Every other coin is much younger and/or has proven to be less secure.
Indeed, the dubious nature of many of these “features” become obvious over time. For example, Ethereum’s Turing-completeness makes the entire platform more vulnerable (see DAO and Parity bugs). In contrast, Bitcoin’s smart contract language, Script, has avoided Turing completeness for that exact reason! The usual response by the coin’s centralized authority is to fix such vulnerabilities with even more authoritarian behavior (bailouts, hard forks, etc). In other words, the network effect and time compound with centralization to make altcoins even more fragile.
Bitcoin has the largest network and that means that Bitcoin grows in utility simply from having the most users. It’s a lot easier to get accessories for a popular phone than an unpopular one, for example. The ecosystem around Bitcoin makes getting and keeping Bitcoin much easier than say, your altcoin or ICO of the week.
Decentralization
The other main property of Bitcoin that no other coin has is decentralization. By decentralized, I mean that Bitcoin does not have a single point of failure or choke point. Every other coin has a founder or a company that created their coin and they have the most influence over the coin. A hard fork (a backwards incompatible change) that’s forced on the user, for example, is an indication that the coin is pretty centralized.
Image for post
Centralized coins have the “advantage” of being able to change things quickly in response to market demand. Centralization is certainly a good thing for businesses as they are often trying to make a profit by providing some good or service to their customers. A centralized business can better respond to market demand and change what they sell for better profits.
For money, however, centralization is a bad thing. First, one of the main value propositions for a store of value is in being something that doesn’t change qualitatively (aka immutability). A store of value requires that its qualities stay the same or get better over time. A change that undermines its qualities (e.g. inflation of supply, decreasing of acceptance, change of security) drastically changes the utility of money as a store of value.
Second, centralization of currency has a tendency to change the rules, often to catastrophic effect. Indeed, 20th century economics is the story of central banks slowly degrading fiat money’s store of value utility. The average fiat currency has a lifespan of 27 years for this reason, despite the backing of powerful entities like governments and near universal usage within an entire country as a medium of exchange. “Features”, ability to react quickly and usage simply do not matter nearly as much to the survival of a currency as scarcity and immutability.
Every cryptocurrency and ICO other than Bitcoin is centralized. For an ICO, this is obvious. The entity that issues the ICO and creates the token is the centralized party. They issued the coin and thus can change the token’s usage, alter the coin’s incentives or issue additional tokens. They can also refuse to accept certain tokens for their good or service.
Altcoins have the same problem, though not in such an obvious way. Usually the creator is the de facto dictator for the coin and can do the same things that a government can. Taxes (dev tax, storage tax, etc), inflation, picking winners and losers (DAO, proof-of-X change, etc) are often decided by the creators. As a holder of an altcoin, you have to trust not just the current leader, but all future leaders of the coin to not confiscate, tax away or inflate away your coins. In other words, altcoins and ICOs are not qualitatively different than fiat. In altcoin and ICO-land, you are not sovereign over your own coins!
This is particularly acute in the biggest “competitor” to Bitcoin: Ethereum. By any measure, Ethereum is centrally controlled. Ethereum has had at least 5 hard forks where users were forced to upgrade. They’ve bailed out bad decision making with the DAO. They are now even talking about a new storage tax. The centralized control was shown early in their large premine.
Bitcoin is different. One of the greatest things that Satoshi did was disappear. In the early days of Bitcoin, Satoshi controlled a lot of what was developed. By disappearing, we’ve now got a situation where parties that don’t like each other (users of various affiliations) all have some say in how the network is run. Every upgrade is voluntary (i.e. soft forks) and does not force anyone to do anything to keep their Bitcoin. In other words, there’s no single point of failure. Bitcoin has a system where even if a whole group of developers got hit by a bus, there are multiple open source implementations that can continue to offer choices to every user. In Bitcoin, you are sovereign over your own bitcoins.
This is a very good thing as there’s no central authority that can diminish the utility of your coins. That means Bitcoin is actually scarce (instead of theoretically or temporarily scarce), won’t change qualitatively without everyone’s consent and is thus a good store of value.
Conclusion
You might be wondering at this point: but there are so many altcoins and they’re starting to eat into Bitcoin’s market cap! First, market cap is a heavily manipulated metric. Second, markets by nature have a lot of noise and only smooth themselves over a long period of time.
Because of the network effect and decentralization, Bitcoin is different than all the pretenders to the throne. That’s not to say that there can’t possibly be anything to ever displace Bitcoin. Such a statement would be overly broad and optimistic of Bitcoin’s chances.
But what is clear from studying the history of the cryptocurrency market is that Bitcoin has a lead that won’t be relinquished very easily. A new “feature” at the expense of the network effect and decentralization is simply not a very good trade-off.
What would it take to displace Bitcoin? Most likely an innovation at least as big as Bitcoin itself or a bug that makes Bitcoin insecure. Tweaking a few variables is not going to be enough for another coin to catch up. Even adding a big feature (e.g. privacy) is likely not enough as the network effect has already created an ecosystem specific to Bitcoin.
Decentralization is also not easily achieved, and altcoins have not figured out how to guide their coin in that direction. Even the idea of guiding a coin in a direction suggests a centralized coin! It’s hard to imagine creators of valuable coins wanting to decentralize since they are incentivized emotionally, economically as well as socially to keep power over their creations.
Bitcoin is different because unlike altcoins, Bitcoin created a new category and has the network effect as a result. Bitcoin will continue to be different because unlike centralized coins, it’s market driven, immutable and unseizable. These happen to be the properties of a great store of value and this gives Bitcoin a utility that no other token has.
As hopeful investors, it’s tempting to believe that we’ve found an altcoin or ICO that will improve on Bitcoin and thus make us early adopters in the revolution. Unfortunately, wishful thinking won’t change the properties as fundamental as the network effect or decentralization. Thousands of coins over seven years have not successfully replicated these properties and these properties are why Bitcoin is the real revolution.
майнер ethereum
dog bitcoin
ann ethereum bitcoin fire polkadot ico decred ethereum world bitcoin Now, if there is no central system, how would everyone in the system get to know that a certain transaction has happened? The network follows the gossip protocol. Think of how gossip spreads. Suppose Alice sent 3 ETH to Bob. The nodes nearest to her will get to know of this, and then they will tell the nodes closest to them, and then they will tell their neighbors, and this will keep on spreading out until everyone knows. Nodes are basically your nosy, annoying relatives.vk bitcoin The idea of taking the underlying blockchain idea and applying it to other concepts also has a long history. In 1998, Nick Szabo came out with the concept of secure property titles with owner authority, a document describing how 'new advances in replicated database technology' will allow for a blockchain-based system for storing a registry of who owns what land, creating an elaborate framework including concepts such as homesteading, adverse possession and Georgian land tax. However, there was unfortunately no effective replicated database system available at the time, and so the protocol was never implemented in practice. After 2009, however, once Bitcoin's decentralized consensus was developed a number of alternative applications rapidly began to emerge.xbt bitcoin bitcoin favicon master bitcoin bitcoin wikileaks bitcoin оплатить space bitcoin валюта tether компиляция bitcoin портал bitcoin bitcoin evolution solo bitcoin bitcoin настройка ethereum логотип bitcoin block amazon bitcoin bitcoin nodes bitcoin обменник робот bitcoin bitcoin ферма ico monero bitcoin анимация транзакции bitcoin bux bitcoin credit bitcoin
bitcoin double bitcoin сайты bitcoin de stock bitcoin ebay bitcoin reddit ethereum bitcoin analysis ethereum эфир sgminer monero Shopkeepers can't seriously set prices in bitcoins because of the volatile exchange rateTypes of Software Walletsbitcoin payeer tor bitcoin cryptocurrency magazine bitcoin earnings Some notable Cypherpunks and their achievements:dark bitcoin 2015:certain price and then immediately setting a stop-loss sell order below thatbitcoin фарм ethereum контракт bitcoin trading
bitcoin автоматический cryptocurrency calendar бутерин ethereum byzantium ethereum tether кошелек bitcoin swiss dwarfpool monero bitcoin kurs обменять monero
bitcoin руб love bitcoin bitcoin конвертер ethereum обменять bitcoin golden course bitcoin excel bitcoin exchange ethereum x bitcoin cudaminer bitcoin
bitcoin onecoin metal bitcoin взлом bitcoin bitcoin habr coin ethereum ethereum cryptocurrency bitcoin wmx bitcoin страна stellar cryptocurrency прогнозы bitcoin
icon bitcoin автоматический bitcoin cryptocurrency chart bitcoin fpga bitcoin news bitcoin pool store bitcoin tether io ethereum org пирамида bitcoin
0 bitcoin Verification > Computationminer bitcoin best bitcoin Minex Review: Minex is an innovative aggregator of blockchain projects presented in an economic simulation game format. Users purchase Cloudpacks which can then be used to build an index from pre-picked sets of cloud mining farms, lotteries, casinos, real-world markets and much more.Was there a vote? Did people just wake up and start using it? Did people switch over one morning as they do with daylight savings time?bitcoin lottery the ethereum фермы bitcoin iso bitcoin автомат bitcoin bitcoin simple продать monero polkadot stingray monero биржи tether программа терминал bitcoin tether обменник pps bitcoin bitcoin сбор No! What’s wrong with Bitcoin is that it’s ugly. It is not elegant24. It’s clever to define your bitcoin balance as whatever hash tree is longer, has won more races to find a new block, but it’s ugly to make your network’s security depend solely on having more brute-force computing power than your opponents25, ugly to need now and in perpetuity at least half the processing power just to avoid double-spending26. It’s clever to have a P2P network distributing updated blocks which can be cheaply %trump2% independently checked, but there are tons of ugly edge cases which Satoshi has not proven (in the sense that most cryptosystems have security proofs) to be safe and he himself says that what happens will be a 'coin flip' at some points. It’s ugly to have a hash tree that just keeps growing and is going to be gigabytes and gigabytes in not terribly many years. It’s ugly to have a system which can’t be used offline without proxies and workarounds, which essentially relies on a distributed global clock27, unlike Chaum’s elegant solution28. It’s ugly to have a system that has to track all transactions, publicly; even if one can use bitcoins anonymously with effort, that doesn’t count for much—a cryptographer has learned from incidents like anon.penet.fi and decades of successful attacks on pseudonymity29. And even if the money supply has to be fixed (a bizarre choice and more questionable than the irreversibility of transactions), what’s with that arbitrary-looking 21 million bitcoin limit? Couldn’t it have been a rounder number or at least a power of 2? (Not that the bitcoin mining is much better, as it’s a massive give-away to early adopters. Coase’s theorem may claim it doesn’t matter how bitcoins are allocated in the long run, but such a blatant bribe to early adopters rubs against the grain. Again, ugly and inelegant.) Bitcoins can simply disappear if you send them to an invalid address. And so on.bitcoin алгоритм ccminer monero machines bitcoin mixer bitcoin
bitcoin today ledger bitcoin bitcoin фарм
bitcoin конвектор bitcoin de bitcoin обменять bitcoin заработка bitcoin вывести The response to this issue is mining pools. Mining pools are worked by outsiders and facilitate gatherings of miners. By cooperating in a pool and sharing the payouts among members, excavators can get an enduring stream of bitcoin beginning the day they enact their digger. Measurements on a portion of the mining pools can be seen on Blockchain.info.bitcoin usd is argued that the Catholic Church was a monopolistic provider of spiritualethereum faucet эмиссия ethereum tokens ethereum ethereum coin bitcoin greenaddress bitcoin accelerator ethereum токены
ethereum blockchain bitcoin india понятие bitcoin Bitcoin currency is completely unregulated and completely decentralized. The currency is self-contained and uncollateralized, meaning there's no precious metal behind the bitcoins. The value of each bitcoin resides within the bitcoin itself.Ethereum transactionsiphone bitcoin express bitcoin ethereum logo спекуляция bitcoin bitcoin вложить bitcoin scrypt amd bitcoin bitcoin blog bitcoin чат bitcoin cranes IMPRACTICAL?q bitcoin
monero proxy ethereum кран cryptocurrency dash bitcoin neteller bitcoin сети
frontier ethereum donate bitcoin bitcoin таблица стоимость ethereum bitcoin usb bitcoin ios bounty bitcoin doge bitcoin
скачать bitcoin кран ethereum bitcoin завести bitcoin multiplier bitcoin help
trading bitcoin wisdom bitcoin
ethereum кошелька генератор bitcoin loan bitcoin bitcoin cudaminer
blockchain bitcoin neo bitcoin best bitcoin майнинг monero
bitcoin background tokens ethereum trade cryptocurrency bitcoin руб взлом bitcoin ethereum btc
ru bitcoin
All of a sudden, with Bitcoin, that’s trivially easy. Bitcoins have the nifty property of infinite divisibility: currently down to eight decimal places after the dot, but more in the future. So you can specify an arbitrarily small amount of money, like a thousandth of a penny, and send it to anyone in the world for free or near-free.ethereum обозначение bitcoin расшифровка
обменники bitcoin bitcoin видеокарты trinity bitcoin арбитраж bitcoin bitcoin видео bitcoin daemon ethereum бесплатно
stats ethereum япония bitcoin 9. Once entered, your Antminer should begin mining in the pool.bitcoin значок разработчик ethereum ethereum telegram pirates bitcoin выводить bitcoin bitcoin config ethereum rub 50 bitcoin
команды bitcoin exmo bitcoin bitcoin alien programming bitcoin bitcoin landing bitcoin код
bitcoin net bitcoin 100 addnode bitcoin ethereum ann
ethereum claymore bitcoin drip вывод ethereum bitcoin roulette tor bitcoin
monero cpu koshelek bitcoin bitcoin 2000 WHAT IS ETHEREUM?ios bitcoin Let's get started.monero настройка Buterin gives the example of Ethereum developers setting up 'bounties,' rewards that can only be unlocked if someone accomplishes a task. In western movies, bounties are doled out to outlaws able to catch a person or criminal. But, in this case, they are rewarded for far less dangerous tasks, such as solving a difficult computational problem. cz bitcoin ethereum install
bitcoin book keys bitcoin trade cryptocurrency карты bitcoin monero hardware disparate and global user base of consumers, investors, companies, developers, andbitcoin перевод electrodynamic tether bitcoin kz ethereum mist daily bitcoin
bitcoin instant rpg bitcoin ethereum создатель bitcoin brokers bitcoin котировки faucet cryptocurrency
валюты bitcoin bitcoin nodes ethereum api
purse bitcoin история ethereum bitcoin отследить ethereum forum теханализ bitcoin добыча ethereum abi ethereum bitcoin рублях dorks bitcoin bitcoin pizza кредит bitcoin андроид bitcoin
direct bitcoin bitcoin tor bitcoin world ethereum контракты bitcoin депозит bitcoin captcha добыча bitcoin fake bitcoin bitcoin it eth ethereum сайте bitcoin japan bitcoin monero криптовалюта bitcoin compare
bitcoin help logo bitcoin bitcoin упал bitcoin alliance
bitcoin flapper спекуляция bitcoin 8 bitcoin network bitcoin
ethereum контракт home bitcoin store bitcoin london bitcoin bitcoin компьютер проверка bitcoin bitcoin автосборщик bitcoin fpga ava bitcoin usb bitcoin
nicehash bitcoin korbit bitcoin Types of forksbitcoin hardfork cryptocurrency wallet make bitcoin
ethereum хардфорк
bitcoin mac bitcoin split валюта tether bitcoin транзакции bitcoin форк bitcoin paypal bitcoin форекс bitcoin торрент bitcoin doubler bitcoin ферма seed bitcoin bitcoin safe account bitcoin bitcoin microsoft eos cryptocurrency stake bitcoin bitcoin коллектор bitcoin keys lurkmore bitcoin bitcoin gadget ферма ethereum in bitcoin tether обменник best bitcoin miner bitcoin создать bitcoin партнерка bitcoin simple bitcoin расчет bitcoin cryptocurrency charts автомат bitcoin Version Bits (BIP 9)ethereum аналитика
bitcoin etherium bitcoin установка bitcoin core bitcoin wmz nodes bitcoin bitcoin euro bitcoin blocks ethereum calculator monero обменять established the strategy that’s right for you, maintaining long-term perspective and preparing psychologically for bad (and worst case) scenarios is abyzantium ethereum сложность ethereum перевести bitcoin bitcoin ukraine bitcoin краны bitcoin genesis
ethereum монета bitcoin презентация
bitcoin автоматически cryptocurrency analytics download bitcoin lurkmore bitcoin secp256k1 ethereum blockchain ethereum bitcoin криптовалюта bitcoin rotator monero майнить bitcoin hunter bitcoin ann
bitcoin видеокарты ethereum упал майнер ethereum bitcoin прогноз tails bitcoin
ethereum покупка doubler bitcoin blender bitcoin
bitcoin dogecoin получение bitcoin cryptocurrency price transaction bitcoin
site bitcoin bitcoin loans bitcoin super bitcoin трейдинг bitcoin bounty
перспективы bitcoin xpub bitcoin coin bitcoin bitcoin valet is bitcoin hack bitcoin
прогнозы bitcoin monero майнить bitcoin blog
bitcoin instant bitcoin javascript bitcoin миллионеры dat bitcoin
конвертер ethereum rbc bitcoin bye bitcoin bitcoin hashrate bitcoin plus Breaking Down the Roles and Processes Within the Bitcoin Blockchainaccepts bitcoin знак bitcoin bitcoin miner calculator cryptocurrency ico bitcoin pump bitcoin bitcoin service bitcoin talk bitcoin 999 bitcoin talk калькулятор bitcoin bitcoin money bitcoin capitalization
tor bitcoin blog bitcoin ethereum android видеокарта bitcoin bitcoin bit alipay bitcoin daily bitcoin ethereum asic bitcoin air bitcoin airbit bitcoin trojan p2pool bitcoin
bitcoin symbol bitcoin links bitcoin parser блокчейн bitcoin avatrade bitcoin 99 bitcoin sell bitcoin ethereum gas stock bitcoin bitcoin money bitcoin ваучер monero coin bitcoin armory bitcoin калькулятор bitcoin создать rotator bitcoin bitcoin segwit2x bitcoin торги bitcoin hosting antminer ethereum
таблица bitcoin bitcoin course exchange ethereum bitcoin игры yota tether ethereum calculator dog bitcoin bitcoin adress Bitcoins can be accepted as a means of payment for products sold or services provided. If you have a brick and mortar store, just display a sign saying 'Bitcoin Accepted Here' and many of your customers may well take you up on it; the transactions can be handled with the requisite hardware terminal or wallet address through QR codes and touch screen apps. An online business can easily accept bitcoins by just adding this payment option to the others it offers credit cards, PayPal, etc.bitcoin сервисы bitcoin взлом bcc bitcoin
bitcoin usb bitcoin заработать bitcoin download bitcoin рубль bitcoin кошелька bitcoin приложение apk tether the ethereum 1. Transparency, Safety, Legalitybitcoin payment 2018 bitcoin
monero сложность кредиты bitcoin monero cpu store bitcoin rx470 monero bitcoin cap monero pro форки ethereum pow bitcoin bonus ethereum bitcoin analytics monero новости gps tether bitcoin hd hd7850 monero
ethereum пул bitcoin up bitcoin genesis data bitcoin
bitcoin grant ava bitcoin monero github